controversial

Meat is Murder

Think you know how your friend would answer?

Play Do You Really Know Me?Includes this prompt
0For
0Against

"Meat is Murder" is the second studio album by the English rock band the Smiths, released on 11 February 1985 through Rough Trade Records. Building on their debut, the record incorporates more overtly political lyrics, especially the pro‑vegetarian title track, while showcasing Johnny Marr’s intricate guitar work and Morrissey’s distinctive vocal style. The album reached number one on the UK Albums Chart and has since been cited in various lists of influential indie and post‑punk records.

Arguments For

  • The album expanded the Smiths' sound with more political lyrics and varied instrumentation.
  • Its title track became an anthem for animal‑rights activism and raised awareness of vegetarianism.
  • Critics praise its melodic guitar work by Johnny Marr and Morrissey's distinctive vocal delivery.
  • The record reached number one in the UK and is frequently listed among influential indie albums.
  • Its blend of melancholy pop and earnest messaging has endured for decades.

Arguments Against

  • Some listeners find the album's overt political messaging heavy‑handed or preachy.
  • Compared to the band's debut, the songwriting can feel repetitive and less hook‑laden.
  • Production choices, while detailed, sometimes obscure the rawness that characterized earlier work.
  • The album's focus on sombre themes may limit its appeal to listeners seeking upbeat music.
  • Certain critics argue that the album lacks the cohesive brilliance of later Smiths releases.

Discussion

Play a game before joining the discussion.

No comments yet.

Now put your friendship to the test

Answer five prompts, predict each other, and see who really knows whom.

Play Do You Really Know Me?